Close Menu
    Vereinigtes Königreich

    Welby sagt, Sterbehilfegesetz sei „gefährlich“


    Welby sagt, Sterbehilfegesetz sei „gefährlich“

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cn9dn42xqg4o

    Von Tartan_Samurai

    View 33 Comments

    33 Comments

    1. juanito_f90 on

      The only dangerous thing here is lying to people to make them believe in a beardy sky wizard.

      Why shouldn’t people have the right to control the end game of their life?

      I’m certainly not going to be a burden on my children and/or the heath service once I’m only fit for scrap.

    2. Apprehensiv3Eye on

      I understand the need for strict criteria and safeguards, but having watched my grandfather suffer horribly in the last few years of his life, followed by watching my mother spend the last few weeks of her life in absolute hell, I would sooner kill myself while I still had the ability to do so than be admitted to hospital with a progressive disease that will result in me slowly losing all of my dignity and control over my own fate.

      Religion shouldn’t even come into the debate.

    3. Eliqui123 on

      Keep your religious views out of my politics, Welby.

      If he was calling for more stringent checks and balances, fair enough, but he’s not. He’s using the slippery slope fallacy to fear monger and take away people’s right to a pain-free, dignified death.

      While of sound mind and body I’m *very* happy to sign something to say that in the event of terminal illness I can choose when to be put to sleep. I’m also okay with the remote possibility that someone coerces me to do it sooner, or that I change my mind and can’t communicate it – to me, even those scenarios would be preferable to dying in agony (and at the time it becomes relevant I’m going to be dying soon anyway).

      My body, my choice. *(Edit: if you’re determined to focus in on one phrase, at least try not to ignore everything else in the post that gives it context, and then incorrectly extrapolated from it. Thanks)*

    4. IndependentOpinion44 on

      Where there’s god, there’s war.

      Religion is dangerous.

    5. Random_Reddit_bloke on

      Religious “leaders” need to stay the fuck out of this conversation- when somebody’s quality of life is so utterly unbearable, and is only going to worsen, nobody other than them should be able to influence what happens next, and certainly not someone that thinks they have a direct line to an all powerful being. Fucking charlatans.

    6. techbear72 on

      Christians from his particular sect should feel free to not use assisted dying, but there’s no reason why this man’s opinion on it should affect the rest of us.

    7. Cute_Ad_9730 on

      I believe if any ‘religion’ makes a significant contribution to your thought process, either you’ve got a mental health problem or you are not being honest about your motivation. Trying to impose you ‘beliefs’ onto other people is ludicrous. Self determined suicide should become a perfectly acceptable decision for people who are normally considered mentally capable.

    8. Gaming_Stoned on

      I find his religion dangerous but i’m not writing articles about it in the paper.

    9. Illustrious_Use_6008 on

      Why are these religious twats so scared about death? It’s literally logic, I don’t want to spend my last years of my life disintegrating due to dementia while I could leave with dignity.

    10. Charming_Pirate on

      Good thing religion has no voice in politics or science, then.

    11. No_Study_2459 on

      I’ve been saying this for years. You cannot have a nhs and assisted dying. People are going to be pressured into killing themselves. What if a man has cancer can’t work and will lose everything for his family. Or an old person taking up resources that could help many more people. Or a young person ill with a lot of healthy organs that could save a lot of lives.

      This hasn’t gone well in Canada it will go even worse here with the state of the nhs. It may seem like assisted dying is the only way to get decent timely treatment

    12. Nice-Substance-gogo on

      Guy who believes in fairy tales shouldn’t get involved in politics.

    13. Nice-Substance-gogo on

      He’s just looking out for the power of the church over old ladies and believers. They want a monopoly on what is right and wrong on death while people continue to suffer.

    14. slackermannn on

      It’s dangerous to ask opinions about this topic to people that are not suffering! When are they going to ask people that are stuck suffering? Cure all diseases and you won’t have this issue. Until then, allow people not to have to suffer, at times for decades before passing. It’s cruel. And to top it all, everybody is like “life is a gift”, “dying makes people around you sad” and yet many times people going through a terminal or chronic conditions lose their relationship, friends and even family connections. This is the cruel reality of illness. But somehow we’re not be given understanding or empathy. We’re just have to be told off by this trash.

    15. neverdidseenadumberQ on

      When an animal is dying an agonising death, we put it out of its misery and all agree 100% that it’s the right thing to do. Only humans have to suffer the medieval-torture-like indignity of a death from something like bowel cancer. Why?

    16. Accomplished-Try-658 on

      Anyone who doesn’t want to live, shouldn’t have to.  Barbaric to allow people to live in misery.

      Definable shouldn’t be seeking opinions from some priest.

    17. alexblueuk on

      Religious people are welcome to follow the views of their religion and die naturally.

      The rest of us would like the option to choose.

    18. mumwifealcoholic on

      Fuck you, Justin.

      And the fictional horse you rode in on. You and your opinions are not relevant to modern life.

      My body MY choice.

    19. Mjukplister on

      Id rather have 1 person die too soon than have 100 languish in agony . It’s time . I remember bloody debating this at secondary school

    20. Hellohibbs on

      A man whose only skill is being well versed in a magic fiction book should not be seen as a credible authority on anything.

    21. Theodin_King on

      Not as dangerous as psychologically traumatising children with the concept of hell.

    22. MarcusSuperbuz on

      So if you belong to his church don’t do it?

      OK the rest of us may do as we chose with our own lives.

    23. Vanster101 on

      In 2023 in Washington, Oregon, and Canada the percentage of those who said not wanting to be a burden to friends/family was a major factor in opting for ‘assisted dying’ was 56%, 45%, and 36% respectively.
      These percentages have increased since introduction. It is not a slippery slope but a real consequence.
      The question is are we happy as a society with that future for us?

    24. Klumber on

      You know what is dangerous? Keeping people alive when they are ready to go. Trapping them in a moral web that normalises suffering and in fact hails it as ‘penance for your sins’.

      People have a right to self determination.

    25. GondorfTheG on

      The “slippery slope” of letting people do what they want. Christians don’t like the sheep making their own decisions. Fuck this guy.

    26. vms-crot on

      His religious opinion on medical matters is entirely irrelevant. Even more irrelevant if his opinion includes people that don’t follow his sky daddy religion.

    27. Caerum on

      The UK should take a look at what the Netherlands does.
      At least my grandparents and mother died with dignity and not in absolute agony. I can’t imagine what would have happened to them if they lived in the UK.
      It’s absolutely heartwrenching to think about.

    29. Sad-Personality8493 on

      He’s speaking like the Church is still relevant. It’s not 1751 anymore. No one cares.

    30. Mrdiglit on

      This guy !

      what is more dangerous and sad is letting someone rot in bed unhappy. And in some cases put families in money trouble.
      This would also save the tax payer lots of money in many cases along with making space.
      Close family sign papers along with one external person a doctor or undertaker.

      This brings peace.

    32. Nicki3000 on

      This guy’s whole job revolves around there being a magic man in the sky. Maybe he shouldn’t have a say in this.

    33. TrashbatLondon on

      “Slippery slope” arguments are so deeply dishonest. It allows someone to smear any reasonable argument as extreme.

      In the real work, gay marriage didn’t lead to people marrying animals, we don’t have 39 week abortions, gay adoption hasn’t acted as “recruitment” and we don’t have any other the other paranoid fantasies the church have dreamed up to scare people away from progressive law making.

    Leave A Reply