Twitch ändert seine Richtlinien zu hasserfüllten Inhalten und schließt „Zionist“ als potenzielle Beleidigung nach Kritik ein

https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/twitch-changes-hateful-content-policy-zionist-term-rcna180406

30 Comments

  1. Brain_Dead_Goats on

    For those who won’t read it, basically if you just swap in Zionist for Jew or Israeli and then use a slur, it’s not okay. If you’re critiquing the political project, it’s fine.

  2. ControlCAD on

    From Nbc news:

    > Twitch has revised its “Hateful Content Policy” to include “Zionist” as a potential slur following mounting criticism over Israel-Gaza war content on the platform.

    > The platform announced the change in a blog post Friday, writing that “using the term ‘Zionist’ to attack or demean another individual or group of people on the basis of their background or religious belief is against our rules.”

    > The platform said that, as part of its policy, it prohibits “the use of terms that may not be harmful or abusive in isolation, but can be used as a slur or to denigrate others in certain contexts.”

    > The term “Zionism” is often associated with a political movement that begun in the 19th century, prior to the founding of Israel, to create a nation-state for the Jewish people.

    > “We recognize that ‘Zionist’ and ‘Zionism’ also refer to a political movement,” Twitch wrote in its blog post. “Using the term to refer to the political movement, whether in a supportive or critical way, does not violate our Hateful Conduct policy. Our goal isn’t to stifle conversation about or criticism of an institution or ideology, but to prevent coded hate directed at individuals and groups of people.”

    > The policy change comes after critics of the Amazon-owned streaming service — including lawmaker Rep. Ritchie Torres, D-N.Y., and the Anti-Defamation League — argued that hate toward Jewish people has prevailed on Twitch in the past year.

    > When asked about the criticism, a spokesperson for the streaming platform previously referred NBC News to a Nov. 1 blog post in which Twitch CEO Dan Clancy reiterated that “hate and harassment have no place on Twitch.”

    > Twitch is the latest social media platform to attempt to draw lines around acceptable speech related to the Israel-Hamas conflict. In July, Meta — which owns Facebook and Instagram — enacted a similar policy, changing its rules to restrict the use of the word “Zionists,” saying the term had often become a proxy for hate speech against Jews.

    > Compared to other online platforms, Twitch had largely dodged controversies involving content over the war between Israel and Gaza — until this fall, when criticism online toward the platform began to escalate.

    > In October, Twitch was accused of disabling sign-ups for the platform from some users in Israel and the Palestinian territories. The platform issued an apology, writing that it had “temporarily disabled sign ups with email verification in Israel and Palestine” after Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on Israel in order to “prevent uploads of graphic material related to the attack and to protect the safety of users.”

    > Sign-ups to the platform were not entirely disabled, according to Twitch, as users could choose to sign up with phone verification. However, the platform said it “inadvertently … did not re-enable email verification sign ups for either region.”

    > Twitch had similarly issued a 14-day suspension to an account run by Zack “Asmongold” Hoyt after he made comments about the death of Palestinians in Gaza, saying they come from an “inferior culture.” Hoyt posted a video response walking back the comments. He also posted a statement on X, writing, in part, “Of course no one deserves to have their life destroyed even if they do things or have views I find regressive.”

    > Clancy, Twitch’s CEO, wrote in his November blog post that the platform does not condone “racism, hatred, or harassment of any kind, including antisemitism and Islamophobia.”

    > He said Twitch works “hard to ensure that our community is a safe place.”

  3. MaliceTheMagician on

    Isn’t this like banning for calling someone a nazi? It’s not specifically racial, plenty of none Jewish zionists in America, same goes for none white nazis.
    I’m not really picking a side here, I’m genuinely asking for input

  4. That’s pretty funny since some people identify with that label and say it shouldn’t mean anything bad

  5. eatingpotatochips on

    The Israeli foreign interference arm strikes again! Israel is the only country which enjoys an exception to being considered foreign interference in domestic affairs.

  6. It’s an overcorrection to placate freaks in the internet claiming pro palestine creators are antisemetic. The ADL is a joke of an organization.

  7. There’s nothing wrong with being white but fuck white supremacists. 

    There’s nothing wrong with being Jewish but fuck Jewish supremacists.

  8. TitaniumGoldAlloyMan on

    Are they also going to forbid the word Nazi to make the racist fucks feelings not hurt? The pro Israel lobby is very strong with bribing their way.

  9. obtheobbie on

    How dare we criticize the actual racist involved here. Shame on us.

  10. Masculine_Dugtrio on
  11. ttubehtnitahwtahw1 on

    But then they also include way to sidestep it so it means nothing.

  12. It’s outrageous that Twitch is letting hate groups like the ADL influence their policy.

  13. So we can’t talk about refugees from the Matrix? What is this bullshit?

  14. It’s crazy how different the comments are when the same story was posted to lsf. I’m happy to see a reasonable dialogue on the matter free of brigading.

  15. Good. The “pro Palestinian” protester who called me a “filthy Zionist pig” and spat on me for the crime of being visibly Jewish knew exactly what he meant, just like a lot of twitch users like Hassan’s fan base also know exactly what they mean when they say “Zionist”.

  16. libretumente on

    Fuck entitled people in general, esepcially zionists. Fuck Twitch.

  17. Narrow-Rooster-546 on

    This is a good change. A lot of streamers were saying clearly antisemitic statements but swapping out the word Jew for Zionist.

Leave A Reply