Close Menu
    Technik

    Eltern verklagen Schule, die einem Schüler, der KI zur Erledigung einer Hausaufgabe eingesetzt hat, eine schlechte Note gegeben hat


    Eltern verklagen Schule, die einem Schüler, der KI zur Erledigung einer Hausaufgabe eingesetzt hat, eine schlechte Note gegeben hat

    https://gizmodo.com/parents-sue-school-that-gave-bad-grade-to-student-who-used-ai-to-complete-assignment-2000512000

    View 24 Comments

    24 Comments

    1. oh_gee_a_flea on

      Every day I’m more and more relieved (maybe guilty?) that I backed out of an education degree. Teachers are cut from a different cloth.

    2. thieh on

      Given most of what AI does is plagiarizing and he is using that, it should fall under the rules regarding plagiarism. Did the student back track and sort out the references and rephrase in his own words? I would doubt that given the behaviour of their parents.

    3. voiderest on

      > harmed his chances of getting into Stanford University and other elite schools

      I’m sure those elite schools will love him using ChatGPT to do all his course work instead of learning anything himself. /s

    4. JauntyLurker on

      This upcoming generation is so cooked. Even college kids nowadays cannot conceive of doing their own research without AI.

    5. Consistent-Sea-410 on

      Be funny if they rejected the student due to the litigious nature of the parents

    7. niknight_ml on

      As I tell my seniors, if you think a bad grade on one assignment is keeping you out of the college of your dreams… there’s a lot more stuff that’s actually keeping you out of that college.

    8. 1smoothcriminal on

      How priviledged does one have to be to instead of talk to their son and discipline him that they sue the school instead.

    10. dethb0y on

      if you’re cheating so obviously you get caught, you deserve the penalty.

    12. 255001434 on

      I can’t imagine wanting to be a public school teacher these days.

    15. Youngthicksandwitch on

      Strange way to frame the argument in title, seems equally plausible that he did not use AI and is being wrongfully accused as there’s many such stories

    16. Significant-Branch22 on

      Allowing the kid to have a grade above 0 for that assignment is lenient

    17. Ghune on

      My parents would have punished me for that.

      I guess some people don’t realise that they are harming their kids in the long run.

    18. A-No1FamousTramp on

      Are her parents Barbara Streisand? Drawing national attention to the fact that their progeny is lazy, entitled and a cheat, and that they are a primary reason they are a raising quite the opposite of someone that should earn entrance into a prestigious institution.

    19. EmperorXerro on

      Accusing a student of using AI is already pointless. I just say it seems like the writer had a lot of outside help and if they want to talk about it, I’m available.

      So far they’re happy with a D.

    20. grimace24 on

      Touchy subject but Generative AI is a tool that schools need to regulate. This isn’t the first or last time this will happen. There are tools now that detect AI on paper and digital copies. The kid should have done his own work. A Saturday detention and a grade of D is lenient. It’s basically the kids cheating, most schools would expel for that.

    21. TheFlamingGit on

      I work as a tech in a local middle school. We should if properly funded, have at the most 20 kids per class.
      Right now the average is 30 kids. I see teachers at the end of the day questioning their life choices.

      And don’t get me started on discipline. If you have too many kids in class, you will have the zipperheads, as my dad called them, completely ruining the class for others. It is not one or 2 of them, we are talking 4-6 per class, being disruptive. AND THEY DON’T CARE.

      Threaten them with Silent Lunch, ISS, OSS..They don’t give a flying F. And some of the parents are even worse.

      If you have a kid (I did she is 21 now in college), discipline them at home for god sake. I am not talking about beating them within an inch of their life, but yea gods, stand up to the little terrorists.

    22. eloquent_beaver on

      Hopefully they’ll be sanctioned by the court for filing frivolous suits and wasting the court’s time.

      Their kid learned a valuable life lesson that actions have consequences, but in a relatively safe environment where the consequences are low and before they hit real life with real consequences.

      In university, one plagiarism infraction and you can be dismissed from the university like that. On the job, one act of misconduct and you can be fired like that.

    24. RemarkableJacket2800 on

      Well the parents are right , the school was stupid enough to not bad /regulate the use of ai ,

      Also how the school proved he used ai ?

    Leave A Reply