Europa Universalis 5, ein beliebtes Geschichtsvideospiel, enthält viele Fehler bezüglich der ethnischen Demografie und ich brauche Quellen, um den Entwicklern ihre Fehler im aktuellen Feedback-Thread aufzuzeigen. Ich brauche Bücher, Websites usw. um zu zeigen, dass Albaner schon immer im Kosovo, Epirus, Griechenland und Mazedonien gelebt haben.
https://i.redd.it/bsbmlte9eyad1.jpeg
Von Overall_Matter1239
9 Comments
The game takes place in the year 1337. The culture map works like this
brown=majority albanian
brown with stripes on it=majority albanian with a big minority
brown stripes=albanians are a big minority but not majority
But the brown stripes in Greece are all aramonians and not albanians.
https://preview.redd.it/90t64mitfyad1.jpeg?width=817&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cbc83d6c1a8555e9c66444fd7ef552d1bd421af7
In this map you can see wich part represents what province/city. As you can see Prizren ate Kukes and is shown as majority Serbian. Dibra is somehow majority Bulgarian/Macedonian, not a single part of Macedonia is majority Albanian, Greeks are a majority in Vlore while Albanians got no presence in Greece. As I said the source can be anything as long as I can link its existence.
Is Wikipedia not enough?
There are 0 mistakes in there. Stop coping
Loja as qe ska dale (ende ne development), po kompania qe i ben kto loja strategji psh EU4 ose CK2 eshte e njohur qe sdine me paraqit kultura hiq. Shkojne qesin kulturen hungareze dhe rumune ne te njejtin grup – Njejt si me qit “kulturen” e shkijeve dhe kulturen shqiptare ne te njejtin grup
Sbejne kerkime ose hulumtim hiq, veq ja fusin
Anything from Noel Malcom should help balance things out
it is difficult to find historical data from 1337 for a nation that wrote their first book in 1555. You can only find foreign sources and they might not display the history as you thought.
I didn’t think many other albanians played paradox games
I mean its difficult to trust any medieval sourse,the most safe sources are the omes that are backed by orevious ones.from the help of the community they changed some parts about france so they might do the same in the balkans because mainly in Transylvania they put the romanians as a minority something that is also incorrecr
Here are some key points and sources that illustrate the Albanian presence in these regions:
🇦🇱 Albania
1. **Primary Sources and Historical Records**:
– **Byzantine Chronicles**: Byzantine records, such as those by Michael Attaliates, mention Albanians (Arbanites) in the 11th century, noting their presence in what is now Albania.
– **The Angevin Archives**: These documents from the Kingdom of Naples in the 13th century mention the Albanian principalities and their interactions with the Angevins.
2. **Academic Research**:
– **Noel Malcolm’s “Agents of Empire”**: This book discusses the Albanian principalities and their significant presence in the region during the medieval period.
– **John V.A. Fine Jr.’s “The Late Medieval Balkans”**: This scholarly work provides an overview of the Albanian presence in the region, detailing their settlements and political influence.
🇦🇱 Kosovo
1. **Primary Sources and Historical Records**:
– **Ottoman Defters (Tax Registers)**: These records from the late 15th century document the Albanian population in Kosovo.
– **Medieval Serbian Chronicles**: Some Serbian sources also note the presence of Albanians in Kosovo, particularly in border areas.
2. **Academic Research**:
– **Noel Malcolm’s “Kosovo: A Short History”**: This book provides an analysis of the Albanian presence in Kosovo, supported by historical evidence.
– **Robert Elsie’s “Historical Dictionary of Kosovo”**: This work includes references to the Albanian demographic and cultural presence in Kosovo.
🇦🇱 Greece (Epirus and Western Macedonia)
1. **Primary Sources and Historical Records**:
– **Medieval Byzantine Sources**: These documents mention the presence of Albanians in regions such as Epirus and Western Macedonia from the 11th century onwards.
– **Venetian Documents**: Records from the Venetian Republic note the presence of Albanian communities in parts of Greece.
2. **Academic Research**:
– **David Abulafia’s “The Great Sea”**: This book discusses the migration and settlement of Albanians in Greece, particularly in the context of the medieval Mediterranean world.
– **Nicholas G. L. Hammond’s “Migrations and Invasions in Greece and Adjacent Areas”**: This work explores the movements and settlements of Albanians in medieval Greece.
🇦🇱 Montenegro
1. **Primary Sources and Historical Records**:
– **Ottoman Defters**: Similar to Kosovo, these records document the Albanian population in parts of Montenegro during the late medieval period.
– **Venetian Records**: Documents from the Venetian Republic also note the presence of Albanians in coastal Montenegro.
2. **Academic Research**:
– **Peter Bartl’s “Albanien: Vom Mittelalter bis zur Gegenwart”**: This book provides an overview of the Albanian presence in Montenegro during the medieval period.
– **John V.A. Fine Jr.’s “The Late Medieval Balkans”**: This work also addresses the Albanian settlements in Montenegro.
🇦🇱 North Macedonia
1. **Primary Sources and Historical Records**:
– **Ottoman Defters**: These tax records from the late 15th century show Albanian populations in parts of what is now North Macedonia.
– **Medieval Serbian Chronicles**: Some sources mention the presence of Albanians in border areas of medieval Serbian states, including parts of North Macedonia.
2. **Academic Research**:
– **Noel Malcolm’s “Rebels, Believers, Survivors”**: This book discusses the historical presence of Albanians in the wider Balkan region, including North Macedonia.
– **Robert Elsie’s “Historical Dictionary of Albania”**: This dictionary includes references to the Albanian presence in various regions, including North Macedonia.
🇦🇱 Summary
By combining primary sources such as Byzantine chronicles, Ottoman tax registers, and Venetian documents with academic research by scholars like Noel Malcolm, John V.A. Fine Jr., and others, we can provide substantial evidence for the Albanian presence in Albania, Kosovo, Greece, Montenegro, and North Macedonia during the medieval period. These sources collectively demonstrate that Albanians were a significant demographic and cultural group in these regions.